Schedule a Free AI Intro Workshop
From the Blog_

So everyone Hates Your Redesign? Here’s What to Do Next

By
Published
on
May 1, 2024

So, you’ve just rolled out a shiny new redesign. You’re pumped. Your team’s pumped. Then, the inevitable happens: the internet explodes with outrage. Users are furious, reviews are scathing, and you find yourself drowning in a sea of angry tweets. Breathe. Relax. This is completely normal.

Redesigns are like cilantro—some people love them, some people hate them, and some people will insist they ruin everything. But just because people are vocal about their displeasure doesn’t mean your redesign is doomed. Let’s break down why this happens and what you can do about it.

The Psychology Behind the Outrage

Fear of Change

Humans are creatures of habit. We get used to certain ways of doing things, and when those ways are disrupted, it can feel like someone rearranged our entire house while we were out getting groceries. This is called “change aversion,” and it’s a powerful psychological phenomenon. When Facebook rolls out a new layout or Twitter decides to mess with the timeline (again), it disrupts our established routines, triggering discomfort and resistance.

Loss Aversion

Loss aversion is another key player here. People tend to prefer avoiding losses rather than acquiring equivalent gains. In the context of a redesign, users feel they’ve lost something familiar and comfortable, even if the new design is objectively better. This perceived loss can overshadow any potential benefits.

The Bandwagon Effect

Social media amplifies everything, including outrage. Once a few influential voices start criticizing a redesign, it can quickly snowball into a full-blown bandwagon of discontent. People might join in simply because they see others doing it, not necessarily because they have strong feelings about the changes.

Famous Freakouts (and Recoveries)

Facebook

Remember when Facebook changed its layout in 2008? The backlash was intense. Groups like “1,000,000 Against the New Facebook Layout” sprung up overnight. But guess what? People adapted, and many can’t even remember the old design now. Facebook listened to some feedback, made a few tweaks, but mostly stuck to their guns, confident in their long-term vision.

Twitter

Twitter’s switch from a chronological timeline to an algorithmic one in 2016 was met with a virtual riot. #RIPTwitter trended worldwide. Yet, Twitter held firm, and users eventually got used to it. The algorithmic timeline even improved user engagement in the long run.

Snapchat

Snapchat’s 2018 redesign might be the most infamous example. Users hated it so much that 1.2 million people signed a petition to revert to the old design. Snapchat’s stock took a hit, but the company stayed the course. Over time, the user base grew, and many features from the redesign are now integral to the app’s functionality.

What to Do When the World Hates Your Redesign

Step 1: Stop, Breathe, Relax

First things first, don’t panic. The initial wave of backlash can be overwhelming, but it’s crucial to stay calm and composed. Remember that immediate negative reactions are a normal part of the redesign process.

Step 2: Listen, But Don’t Overreact

It’s important to listen to your users. Pay attention to their feedback and look for common themes. Are there specific features they’re missing? Is there a particular aspect of the design that’s causing confusion? However, it’s equally important not to overreact. Not all feedback is actionable or even valid.

Step 3: Communicate Transparently

Be open about why you made the changes. Explain the rationale behind the redesign and how it aims to improve the user experience. Transparency can go a long way in helping users understand and eventually accept the changes.

Step 4: Iterate and Improve

Use the feedback you’ve gathered to make necessary adjustments. Small tweaks can sometimes make a big difference in user satisfaction. Show your users that you’re responsive and willing to make improvements.

Step 5: Stay the Course

Believe in your vision. If you’ve done your homework and believe the redesign is the right move, stay the course. Major redesigns are often met with resistance, but over time, users adapt. Remember, Facebook, Twitter, and Snapchat all faced intense backlash, but their redesigns ultimately contributed to their long-term success.

Let’s face it, no one likes change—except maybe babies with dirty diapers. So, when the world seems to be collapsing around you because of your redesign, remember that this too shall pass. After all, in a few months, users will probably be clamoring for the “old new design” when the next redesign rolls out.

Conclusion

Redesigns are tough. They challenge the status quo, disrupt routines, and can feel like a personal affront to users who’ve grown attached to the old ways. But they’re also essential for growth and improvement. The backlash is a natural part of the process. By staying calm, listening to feedback, communicating transparently, iterating where necessary, and believing in your vision, you can navigate the storm and come out stronger on the other side. Just remember, even the biggest tech giants faced their share of redesign rage—and lived to tell the tale.